Economic Policy Review Executive Summary

Trends in Financial Market Concentration and Their Implications for Market Stability

Recapping an article from the March 2007 issue
Contact authors
E-mail authors
of the Economic Policy Review, Volume 13, Number 1
View full article PDF

19 pages / 431 kb

Authors: Nicola Cetorelli, Beverly Hirtle, DonaldMorgan, Stavros Peristiani, andJoão Santos

Disclaimer
Index of executive summaries
  • Are concentrated markets—in which a relatively small number of firms hold large market shares—more likely to be disrupted than less concentrated ones? The answer is important to policymakers as well as other market participants concerned about potential threats to market stability.

  • Cetorelli et al., drawing on academic research as well as introducing new analysis, consider the link between market concentration and the risk or severity of instability. Their review of how U.S. financial market structure has changed over the last decade finds no pervasive pattern of high and increasing concentration. According to the authors, most wholesale credit and capital markets in the United States are only moderately concentrated, and concentration trends are mixed—rising in some markets, falling in others.

  • The article also identifies market characteristics that might lead to greater, or less, concern about the consequences of a large firm's failure in a concentrated market. In particular, it argues that prompt substitution by other firms is a critical factor supporting market resiliency. Substitution is a stabilizing force because it can dampen the upward pressure on prices attributable to the failure of a large firm.

  • The authors’ findings can offer some reassurance to policymakers and others concerned about whether high or rising financial market concentration could suggest greater market instability.

  • The study also makes several recommendations in light of its findings, such as monitoring market concentration and turnover trends and introducing public policies that enhance firm substitution within a given market. Such policies could include promoting standardization of products, ensuring rapid clearing of payments, and monitoring competition to ensure that key players do not become entrenched, and hence irreplaceable, because of privileged access to trading platforms or technologies.


About the Authors

NicolaCetorelli is a senior economist and BeverlyHirtle a senior vice president at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York; DonaldMorgan, StavrosPeristiani, and JoãoSantos are research officers at the Bank.

Disclaimer

The views expressed in this summary are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the position of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York or the Federal Reserve System.